7/1/09
Let's see what NY Times said:
In the weeks just before President Obama took office, his economic advisers made a mistake. They got a little carried away with hope.
To make the case for a big stimulus package, they released their economic forecast for the next few years. Without the stimulus, they saw the unemployment rate — then 7.2 percent — rising above 8 percent in 2009 and peaking at 9 percent next year. With the stimulus, the advisers said, unemployment would probably peak at 8 percent late this year.
We now know that this forecast was terribly optimistic. The jobless rate has already reached 9.4 percent. On Thursday, the Labor Department will announce the latest number, for June, and forecasters are expecting it to rise further. In concrete terms, the difference between the situation that the Obama advisers predicted and the one that has come to pass is about 2.5 million jobs. It’s as if every worker in the city of Los Angeles received an unexpected layoff notice.
There are two possible explanations that the administration was so wrong. And sorting through them matters a great deal, because they point in opposite policy directions.
The first explanation is that the economy has deteriorated because the stimulus package failed. Some critics say that stimulus just doesn’t work, while others argue that this particular package was too small or too badly constructed to make a difference.
The second answer is that the economy has deteriorated in spite of the stimulus. In other words, the patient is not as sick as he would have been without the medicine he received. But he is a lot sicker than doctors realized when they prescribed it.
To me, the evidence is fairly compelling that the second answer is the right one. The stimulus package does seem to have helped. But its impact has been minor — so far — compared with the harshness of the Great Recession.
Unfortunately, the administration’s rose-colored forecast has muddied this picture. So if at some point this year or next the White House decides that the economy needs more stimulus, skeptics will surely brandish that old forecast.
Worst of all, the economy really may need more help.
Now, look at my prediction at 1/1/09 for 2009 outlook:
The S&P 500 will re-test the 750 lows in the first half of 2009, and we will close below 700 by the end of 2009. This bear market will not end in 2009.
Crude oil will stay below $80/barrel for all of 2009.
Gold will break out above $1000/oz.
The VIX will hit over 80 or make new high to 100 for the first time ever.
Unemployment rate will hit over 10.0%. Total Unemployment (U-6) will hit 20%.
Housing prices will keep dropping without finding any bottom.
Commercial real estate values will drop 30-40%. Land development, office space, warehouses, shopping malls, hotels, and resorts will do the worst. Large multi-family properties will do the “best” because they will house all the folks who will lose their homes.
20% of retailers will file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
The bailout money will run out in first half of 2009 and the Fed/Treasury will request an additional package…and be denied. This debate will drag on for months and months.
Numerous local municipalities and/or states will go bankrupt. Many states will be unable to pay out full unemployment benefits.
Yes,I am still very bearish. I do not see how our Bear Market(the worst since great depression as I pointed out in early 2008) can last for only 2 years. The last tech bear market lasted for about 2 1/2 years. In addition, the last 9 bear markets after world war II that all did not involve a global credit crisis! So, there are sure more disappointments ahead the hollow secular bear market ever.
My comment: Some of my observation/predictions are correct. Some are still wait to see. For example, even I am not economist, I am still able seeing unemployment rate will higher than 10% 6 months ago. What are those white house economists thinking about??? What do you think? Folks. Are those economists make a good call?? I am laughing loud to them. For such very easy economic data(Unemployment) that they cannot even predict close in range, what do think they are all able to rescue our nation economy? We will hear new unemployment rate tomorrow for month of June. Now, we are sitting 9.4% already, that very far off from those experts prediction. I guess my 10% guess is still too optimisic. Now, I guess we can see 11% at the end of 2009 so easy. Good luck to all!!